{"claims":[{"confidence_ceiling":"high","id":"a-c1","reasons":["two-independent-high-grade-origin-groups"],"review_status":"reviewed","unresolved_disagreement":false},{"confidence_ceiling":"moderate","id":"a-c2","reasons":["single-origin-conservative-cap"],"review_status":"reviewed","unresolved_disagreement":false},{"confidence_ceiling":"high","id":"a-c3","reasons":["two-independent-high-grade-origin-groups"],"review_status":"reviewed","unresolved_disagreement":false},{"confidence_ceiling":"high","id":"a-c4","reasons":["two-independent-high-grade-origin-groups"],"review_status":"reviewed","unresolved_disagreement":false},{"confidence_ceiling":"high","id":"a-c5","reasons":["two-independent-high-grade-origin-groups"],"review_status":"reviewed","unresolved_disagreement":false},{"confidence_ceiling":"low","id":"b-6g-comparison","reasons":["support-is-weak-partial-or-inferential","unresolved-opposition-conservative-v1"],"review_status":"partial","unresolved_disagreement":true},{"confidence_ceiling":"low","id":"b-climate-water-innovation","reasons":["support-is-weak-partial-or-inferential"],"review_status":"reviewed","unresolved_disagreement":false},{"confidence_ceiling":"high","id":"b-climate-water-need","reasons":["two-independent-high-grade-origin-groups"],"review_status":"reviewed","unresolved_disagreement":false},{"confidence_ceiling":"low","id":"b-space-eo-comparison","reasons":["support-is-weak-partial-or-inferential","unresolved-opposition-conservative-v1"],"review_status":"partial","unresolved_disagreement":true},{"confidence_ceiling":"moderate","id":"c-adaptation-finance","reasons":["single-origin-conservative-cap"],"review_status":"reviewed","unresolved_disagreement":false},{"confidence_ceiling":"low","id":"c-select-quantum","reasons":["support-is-weak-partial-or-inferential"],"review_status":"reviewed","unresolved_disagreement":false},{"confidence_ceiling":"low","id":"c-select-resilience","reasons":["support-is-weak-partial-or-inferential"],"review_status":"reviewed","unresolved_disagreement":false}],"confidence_note":"Ordinal conservative ceilings, not probabilities or source-truth certification.","confidence_scale":["unsupported","low","moderate","high"],"engine":{"bundle_sha256":"0c249e4eb40ff8c7cd38dfb32d9d51051688f8a54a60e79a3518ce3cbba852bb","modules":{"evidence/__init__.py":"310f58694111fc482e4eb06e2d4d31e39389d306e04d96060eb949790dd7bb99","evidence/engine.py":"aaee98d4b3d734cea4e6e553f967de92403381bbb6709d4fae08eaf941c5f7c0","evidence/validation.py":"dd5f38b1bd1a65253b100c802bc4c6f603dd84475f149385bafe16a3f42b7d7b","evidence_gate.py":"7a287fae09be8e01d13a710409f8a10dd4c926337449078137c8b19290e6bc8a"},"python":"3.12.9","version":"evidence-gate.v1"},"input_sha256":"f186a5af6417f9eee026883ad56d59f60f838b2454259d25cd131e70779ae319","packet_assessment":"contested","packet_id":"atlas-outlook-expansion-002","schema_version":"1","sources":[{"credibility_inputs":{"expertise":{"rationale":"NIST issued the cryptographic standards.","score":3},"method":{"rationale":"Direct record of named standards and scope.","score":3},"provenance":{"rationale":"Primary standards authority reporting its own approval.","score":3}},"credibility_rating":"high","id":"a-q1"},{"credibility_inputs":{"expertise":{"rationale":"OECD and EPO combine innovation-policy and patent-data authority.","score":3},"method":{"rationale":"The accessible announcement provides exact reported indicators but this lane did not inspect the full study methodology or underlying dataset.","score":2},"provenance":{"rationale":"Joint OECD/EPO report announcement describing its own current ecosystem study.","score":3}},"credibility_rating":"moderate","id":"a-q5"},{"credibility_inputs":{"expertise":{"rationale":"SCQIS coordinates relevant federal QIS expertise.","score":3},"method":{"rationale":"Authoritative roadmap and examples, but it is not an independent deployment census or commercial-performance study.","score":2},"provenance":{"rationale":"Primary publication of the issuing U.S. interagency policy body.","score":3}},"credibility_rating":"moderate","id":"a-q6"},{"credibility_inputs":{"expertise":{"rationale":"Committee is composed of industry, academic and federal-lab leaders.","score":3},"method":{"rationale":"Direct evidence of the report focus and recommendations, but the full findings were not inspected.","score":2},"provenance":{"rationale":"Primary page of a statutory Presidential advisory committee describing its report.","score":3}},"credibility_rating":"moderate","id":"a-q7"},{"credibility_inputs":{"expertise":{"rationale":"DOE and national labs directly lead the cited program.","score":3},"method":{"rationale":"Direct for program state and roadmap, but older and not evidence that milestones have been completed.","score":2},"provenance":{"rationale":"Primary DOE account of its blueprint and named testbed.","score":3}},"credibility_rating":"moderate","id":"a-q8"},{"credibility_inputs":{"expertise":{"rationale":"NIST authored the framework.","score":3},"method":{"rationale":"Direct for framework content and intended scope.","score":3},"provenance":{"rationale":"Primary framework publication.","score":3}},"credibility_rating":"high","id":"a-s1"},{"credibility_inputs":{"expertise":{"rationale":"ENISA has direct EU cybersecurity remit.","score":3},"method":{"rationale":"The page states the incident basis, while full methodology was not inspected.","score":2},"provenance":{"rationale":"EU cybersecurity agency publication.","score":3}},"credibility_rating":"moderate","id":"a-s2"},{"credibility_inputs":{"expertise":{"rationale":"Primary publisher for regulation status and scope.","score":3},"method":{"rationale":"Direct legal evidence.","score":3},"provenance":{"rationale":"Official EU legal record.","score":3}},"credibility_rating":"high","id":"a-s3"},{"credibility_inputs":{"expertise":{"rationale":"Authoritative for the existence and date of this EU policy instrument.","score":3},"method":{"rationale":"The bounded claim concerns the documented publication, which the official record directly establishes.","score":3},"provenance":{"rationale":"Official European Commission publication record.","score":3}},"credibility_rating":"high","id":"b-ec-water-strategy-2025"},{"credibility_inputs":{"expertise":{"rationale":"EPO is a primary institutional source for the study's patent-analysis record.","score":3},"method":{"rationale":"The inspected summary identifies international patent families and scope but not the study's full classification protocol.","score":2},"provenance":{"rationale":"Official EPO summary of its own patent study.","score":3}},"credibility_rating":"moderate","id":"b-epo-water-patents"},{"credibility_inputs":{"expertise":{"rationale":"ESA is directly responsible for its Earth-observation programme strategy.","score":3},"method":{"rationale":"Strategy and consultation provenance is clear, but it is not an outcome evaluation.","score":2},"provenance":{"rationale":"Official ESA citation and summary of its strategy.","score":3}},"credibility_rating":"moderate","id":"b-esa-eo-strategy-2024"},{"credibility_inputs":{"expertise":{"rationale":"ITU-R is the relevant international radiocommunication standards body.","score":3},"method":{"rationale":"Direct authoritative evidence for the recommendation's status, targets and timetable.","score":3},"provenance":{"rationale":"In-force ITU-R recommendation.","score":3}},"credibility_rating":"high","id":"b-itu-imt2030-2023"},{"credibility_inputs":{"expertise":{"rationale":"JRC is the European Commission's science and knowledge service.","score":3},"method":{"rationale":"Directly describes the perspective and agenda; it does not establish system-level adaptation outcomes.","score":2},"provenance":{"rationale":"Official JRC publication.","score":3}},"credibility_rating":"moderate","id":"b-jrc-eo-adaptation-2025"},{"credibility_inputs":{"expertise":{"rationale":"UNEP publishes a recurring global adaptation assessment.","score":3},"method":{"rationale":"The inspected pages describe the assessment scope and figures but not all model inputs or uncertainty methods.","score":2},"provenance":{"rationale":"Official publisher page and repository record for the report.","score":3}},"credibility_rating":"moderate","id":"b-unep-gap-2024"},{"credibility_inputs":{"expertise":{"rationale":"WMO is the UN specialized agency for meteorology, climate and hydrology.","score":3},"method":{"rationale":"The page identifies data contributors, models and satellite observations, but this inspection did not audit the full report methods.","score":2},"provenance":{"rationale":"Official WMO publication describing its own annual assessment.","score":3}},"credibility_rating":"moderate","id":"b-wmo-water-2025"},{"credibility_inputs":{"expertise":{"rationale":"UN environmental assessment; methods summarized, finance flows and modeled needs have different scopes.","score":3},"method":{"rationale":"Fit for the bounded reported observation; underlying microdata not independently reanalysed.","score":2},"provenance":{"rationale":"Inspected original institutional publication.","score":3}},"credibility_rating":"moderate","id":"c-unep-2025"}],"status":"deterministic-success"}