{"claims":[{"confidence_ceiling":"low","id":"A1","reasons":["support-is-weak-partial-or-inferential"],"review_status":"reviewed","unresolved_disagreement":false},{"confidence_ceiling":"high","id":"E1","reasons":["two-independent-high-grade-origin-groups"],"review_status":"reviewed","unresolved_disagreement":false},{"confidence_ceiling":"high","id":"E2","reasons":["two-independent-high-grade-origin-groups"],"review_status":"reviewed","unresolved_disagreement":false},{"confidence_ceiling":"high","id":"E3","reasons":["two-independent-high-grade-origin-groups"],"review_status":"reviewed","unresolved_disagreement":false},{"confidence_ceiling":"high","id":"E4","reasons":["two-independent-high-grade-origin-groups"],"review_status":"reviewed","unresolved_disagreement":false},{"confidence_ceiling":"high","id":"E5","reasons":["two-independent-high-grade-origin-groups"],"review_status":"reviewed","unresolved_disagreement":false},{"confidence_ceiling":"moderate","id":"E6","reasons":["single-origin-conservative-cap"],"review_status":"reviewed","unresolved_disagreement":false},{"confidence_ceiling":"moderate","id":"E7","reasons":["single-origin-conservative-cap"],"review_status":"reviewed","unresolved_disagreement":false},{"confidence_ceiling":"high","id":"E8","reasons":["two-independent-high-grade-origin-groups"],"review_status":"reviewed","unresolved_disagreement":false},{"confidence_ceiling":"low","id":"F1","reasons":["support-is-weak-partial-or-inferential"],"review_status":"reviewed","unresolved_disagreement":false},{"confidence_ceiling":"low","id":"F2","reasons":["support-is-weak-partial-or-inferential"],"review_status":"reviewed","unresolved_disagreement":false},{"confidence_ceiling":"low","id":"F3","reasons":["support-is-weak-partial-or-inferential","unresolved-opposition-conservative-v1"],"review_status":"reviewed","unresolved_disagreement":true},{"confidence_ceiling":"low","id":"F4","reasons":["support-is-weak-partial-or-inferential"],"review_status":"reviewed","unresolved_disagreement":false},{"confidence_ceiling":"low","id":"F5","reasons":["support-is-weak-partial-or-inferential"],"review_status":"reviewed","unresolved_disagreement":false},{"confidence_ceiling":"low","id":"X1","reasons":["support-is-weak-partial-or-inferential"],"review_status":"reviewed","unresolved_disagreement":false}],"confidence_note":"Ordinal conservative ceilings, not probabilities or source-truth certification.","confidence_scale":["unsupported","low","moderate","high"],"engine":{"bundle_sha256":"0c249e4eb40ff8c7cd38dfb32d9d51051688f8a54a60e79a3518ce3cbba852bb","modules":{"evidence/__init__.py":"310f58694111fc482e4eb06e2d4d31e39389d306e04d96060eb949790dd7bb99","evidence/engine.py":"aaee98d4b3d734cea4e6e553f967de92403381bbb6709d4fae08eaf941c5f7c0","evidence/validation.py":"dd5f38b1bd1a65253b100c802bc4c6f603dd84475f149385bafe16a3f42b7d7b","evidence_gate.py":"7a287fae09be8e01d13a710409f8a10dd4c926337449078137c8b19290e6bc8a"},"python":"3.12.9","version":"evidence-gate.v1"},"input_sha256":"f2774c7283acfe8bac43adced10cc62ec4e346958560a4514bd0c5dd058e5f47","packet_assessment":"contested","packet_id":"synthesis-002-final","schema_version":"1","sources":[{"credibility_inputs":{"expertise":{"rationale":"Company directly operates the assets reported.","score":3},"method":{"rationale":"Audited financial filing with defined accounting disclosures.","score":3},"provenance":{"rationale":"Issuer's SEC filing, strong for its recorded expenditure and stated plans.","score":3}},"credibility_rating":"high","id":"demand-alphabet"},{"credibility_inputs":{"expertise":{"rationale":"National cybercrime reporting authority.","score":3},"method":{"rationale":"Large administrative complaint dataset with explicit reporting limitations.","score":3},"provenance":{"rationale":"Primary FBI reporting dataset.","score":3}},"credibility_rating":"high","id":"demand-cyber"},{"credibility_inputs":{"expertise":{"rationale":"International energy agency with direct energy-system remit.","score":3},"method":{"rationale":"States a global model, comprehensive dataset, and consultation process.","score":3},"provenance":{"rationale":"Primary IEA analytical report.","score":3}},"credibility_rating":"high","id":"demand-energy-ai"},{"credibility_inputs":{"expertise":{"rationale":"International energy analysis agency.","score":3},"method":{"rationale":"Flagship investment inventory with documented scope.","score":3},"provenance":{"rationale":"Primary IEA investment tracking publication.","score":3}},"credibility_rating":"high","id":"demand-energy-investment"},{"credibility_inputs":{"expertise":{"rationale":"Specialist global robotics federation.","score":3},"method":{"rationale":"Reports computed stock and regional installations, but limited method detail in inspected executive summary.","score":2},"provenance":{"rationale":"Trade federation market dataset; original survey microdata is not inspected.","score":2}},"credibility_rating":"moderate","id":"demand-robots"},{"credibility_inputs":{"expertise":{"rationale":"OECD has recognised expertise in innovation statistics and biotechnology policy.","score":3},"method":{"rationale":"The inspected report frames a multi-indicator policy assessment; the patent figure is not by itself a full landscape.","score":2},"provenance":{"rationale":"OECD report cites the March 2025 OECD PCT biotechnology indicator source.","score":3}},"credibility_rating":"moderate","id":"patents-biotech"},{"credibility_inputs":{"expertise":{"rationale":"WIPO is the UN specialist agency for IP and patent analytics.","score":3},"method":{"rationale":"The report defines published patent-family counts, period, model taxonomy and publication-lag limitation.","score":3},"provenance":{"rationale":"WIPO's 2024 patent-landscape publication reporting its own defined global dataset.","score":3}},"credibility_rating":"high","id":"patents-genai"},{"credibility_inputs":{"expertise":{"rationale":"WIPO has subject-matter and patent-data expertise.","score":3},"method":{"rationale":"It distinguishes family volume, recent growth and recency rather than presenting a raw-document count as momentum.","score":3},"provenance":{"rationale":"Primary WIPO patent-analytics report with an explicit momentum construct.","score":3}},"credibility_rating":"high","id":"patents-transport"},{"credibility_inputs":{"expertise":{"rationale":"Original computational science-of-science research team with stated affiliations.","score":3},"method":{"rationale":"Large longitudinal dataset and classifier validation with disclosed limitations; no independent replication performed.","score":2},"provenance":{"rationale":"Versioned original author manuscript, inspected full HTML.","score":3}},"credibility_rating":"moderate","id":"root-ai-science"},{"credibility_inputs":{"expertise":{"rationale":"Primary patent examination and statistical authority.","score":3},"method":{"rationale":"Clearly specified office, application unit, year and comparison; institutional competitiveness framing not adopted.","score":3},"provenance":{"rationale":"Patent office's own administrative statistics release.","score":3}},"credibility_rating":"high","id":"root-epo2025"},{"credibility_inputs":{"expertise":{"rationale":"Program owner is authoritative on finalized awards and program scope; not evidence of eventual technical success.","score":3},"method":{"rationale":"Fit for the bounded reported observation; underlying microdata not independently reanalysed.","score":3},"provenance":{"rationale":"Inspected original institutional publication.","score":3}},"credibility_rating":"high","id":"root-nist"},{"credibility_inputs":{"expertise":{"rationale":"Official research statistics agency; global publication analysis and U.S. R&D surveys.","score":3},"method":{"rationale":"Fit for the bounded reported observation; underlying microdata not independently reanalysed.","score":3},"provenance":{"rationale":"Inspected original institutional publication.","score":3}},"credibility_rating":"high","id":"root-nsf"},{"credibility_inputs":{"expertise":{"rationale":"Intergovernmental STI policy analysis; summary is evidence of reported aggregate and themes, not a forecast validation.","score":3},"method":{"rationale":"Fit for the bounded reported observation; underlying microdata not independently reanalysed.","score":2},"provenance":{"rationale":"Inspected original institutional publication.","score":3}},"credibility_rating":"moderate","id":"root-oecd"},{"credibility_inputs":{"expertise":{"rationale":"Original institutional summary of joint ecosystem/patent analysis; uneven commercial momentum expressly reported.","score":3},"method":{"rationale":"Fit for the bounded reported observation; underlying microdata not independently reanalysed.","score":2},"provenance":{"rationale":"Inspected original institutional publication.","score":3}},"credibility_rating":"moderate","id":"root-quantum"},{"credibility_inputs":{"expertise":{"rationale":"UN environmental assessment; methods summarized, finance flows and modeled needs have different scopes.","score":3},"method":{"rationale":"Fit for the bounded reported observation; underlying microdata not independently reanalysed.","score":2},"provenance":{"rationale":"Inspected original institutional publication.","score":3}},"credibility_rating":"moderate","id":"root-unep"},{"credibility_inputs":{"expertise":{"rationale":"Original employer survey publisher; expectation survey is not representative researcher counts or realized hiring.","score":2},"method":{"rationale":"Fit for the bounded reported observation; underlying microdata not independently reanalysed.","score":2},"provenance":{"rationale":"Inspected original institutional publication.","score":3}},"credibility_rating":"moderate","id":"root-wef"},{"credibility_inputs":{"expertise":{"rationale":"International IP statistical authority.","score":3},"method":{"rationale":"Defines office/origin and patent-family measures and incomplete latest-year technology data.","score":3},"provenance":{"rationale":"Original WIPO global patent statistics publication.","score":3}},"credibility_rating":"high","id":"root-wipi2025"},{"credibility_inputs":{"expertise":{"rationale":"DOE Office of Science program owner.","score":3},"method":{"rationale":"Direct program and participation statements, but the page provides no time series demonstrating growth.","score":2},"provenance":{"rationale":"Primary DOE program record.","score":3}},"credibility_rating":"moderate","id":"science-doe"},{"credibility_inputs":{"expertise":{"rationale":"Commission directorate administers the programme.","score":3},"method":{"rationale":"Direct record of a public funding commitment, not evidence that all expected science or impact occurs.","score":3},"provenance":{"rationale":"Primary European Commission strategy page.","score":3}},"credibility_rating":"high","id":"science-eu"},{"credibility_inputs":{"expertise":{"rationale":"NIH Office of Data Science Strategy is directly responsible for the plan.","score":3},"method":{"rationale":"Strong evidence of NIH's stated program direction; it is not a measured output series.","score":3},"provenance":{"rationale":"Primary NIH strategy page.","score":3}},"credibility_rating":"high","id":"science-nih"}],"status":"deterministic-success"}